Elections

Mayoral race overturned after random drawing, recount and a single ballot challenge

One challenged ballot unseated the incumbent mayor and handed the win to Halyn Roth.

Spring Lake Park’s police department is located in the same building as its city hall.
Spring Lake Park’s mayoral race was likely the closest race of any in the country during the 2026 midterm cycle. (Myotus/CC BY 4.0)

A Minnesota mayor’s race that was first settled by random drawing has flipped after the losing candidate challenged a single ballot.

As reported by CBS News, incumbent Mayor Bob Nelson and challenger Halyn Roth each finished with 1,401 votes in Spring Lake Park, a Minneapolis suburb. The tie sent the race to a tiebreaker drawing.

Nelson won after the drawing of a name placed in a film canister at the Nov. 9 Spring Lake Park City Council meeting. Roth then called for a recount and challenged one ballot, arguing it was not a clear vote for Nelson.

After the recount, the council’s Municipal Canvassing Board voted 3-1 at its Nov. 17 meeting to sustain Roth’s challenge. That put Roth ahead by one vote. The final tally was 1,403 votes for Roth and 1,402 for Nelson, CBS News reported.

“This was a contentious evening, and emotions on both sides were high,” Roth wrote in a Facebook post after the decision. “I will have more to say soon, as I’m still processing this myself. Until then, thank you for your trust and support.”

Roth, an openly gay father, ran on a platform of inclusivity, transparency, and public safety, among other issues.

In a statement to KSTP, Roth acknowledged that Nelson could still challenge the result in the weeks ahead.

“As with any close election, Mayor Nelson has every right to pursue further legal review and have his day in court should he choose to do so,” Roth wrote. “My focus now is on preparing to serve all residents of Spring Lake Park and ensuring a smooth, productive transition for our city.”

Nelson has not publicly commented on the final ruling. After the drawing, though, he acknowledged to WCCO that winning by drawing was a flawed way to keep his seat.

“This seems like it’s something from the 1800s, and now we’re in 2026, so I just feel there’s room for improvement,” Nelson said.


Categories:

Authors

  • Ryan Pitkin is a writer and editor based in Charlotte, where until recently he ran an alternative weekly newspaper called Queen City Nerve. He is also editor of NoDa News, a community newsletter in the neighborhood where he has lived for 15 years.